The Drills We've Worn Out (and What Replaced Them)

|Peter Johnson
Drills ours died

A look back at the drills that carried us for 16 years, the replacements that didn't cut it, and the unlikely eBay find that's outperformed them all.

Losing our old faithfuls

This year we lost two of our old faithful workers: our Hitachi 18-volt battery drill, and our Makita mains-power drill.

Original Hitachi 18v battery drills after 16 years of use

Our original Hitachi drills — great tools that lasted about 16 years, thoroughly abused, drilled holes far bigger than they were designed for, dropped, left outside, and I can't speak highly enough of them. They were made in Japan (all Hitachi tools are now made in China, I'm told).

The first to give up was the Hitachi 18-volt battery drill. It had done a lot of work — dropped, covered in epoxy, asked to drill holes far bigger than it was ever meant for — but it kept going, and was a genuinely amazing drill.

Trying to replace them

So what did we look at as a replacement? First we tried Makita 18-volt drills, but they just couldn't cut the mustard — within two days we'd burnt one out, and the other was sent back faulty.

Makita 18v drill failure Makita 18v drill failure

Makita failures

Our large mains Makita burned out drilling the holes through the keel for the ballast keel — these holes are 52mm in diameter and roughly 700mm in length. It had been a good drill, but it couldn't cope. The replacement was £600, and we weren't convinced the power was even up to the job compared to the one we'd burnt out.

Burned out mains drill after drilling ballast keel holes Burned out mains drill after drilling ballast keel holes

So we were drill-less, and our usual suppliers couldn't offer us anything better. I found a Hitachi 18-volt battery drill and ordered it. It's proved okay, but not a patch on our original Hitachi — it's made in China, it's cheap, and it feels light in your hands; the chuck has been a problem, but it's holding up for now. Would we buy another? Not without looking around first and trying something else. I think Hitachi dropped the ball here — cheaper to make, and it takes the standard 18-volt battery, but the guts of the machine just aren't as good as our first one.

An unlikely winner

As for our new mains drill — that's been an eye-opener. We ordered one off eBay for £98, and it's been great. It's ugly, the switches are chunky, but it has real power, and you can grease the gearbox, which has metal gears. The holes we were grinding out a day at a time with our old Makita mains drill — this beast did all 12 remaining holes in a single day. Top marks so far.

New eBay mains drill

New mains drill

Gearbox grease cover on the new mains drill

The black circular plastic cover lets you grease the gearbox

The new eBay mains drill in use

From eBay, but a genuinely good bit of kit

Peter Johnson

Written by

Peter Johnson

Pete Johnson is the owner of Epoxy Ltd, trading since the late 1990s and supplying MAS epoxy and boatbuilding materials to professional and DIY builders alike, all under the philosophy of "Simple Perfection". When he's not helping customers, he's usually elbow-deep in one of his own projects, from building the 38ft schooner Iracunda from scratch to restoring boats like Junior, a 1950s Yachting Monthly dinghy rescued from the scrap heap. He writes the workshop blog to share the practical, often hard-won lessons learned building and repairing boats with epoxy.